Playing Fair or Taking Advantage? Navigating the Pickleball Dilemma of Targeting Low Mobility Players

Ever found yourself in a pickle on the pickleball court, wondering if you should exploit an opponent’s lack of mobility? It’s a common conundrum many of us face, especially when we’re up against players who might not move as swiftly. Let’s dive into this dilemma and hear from seasoned players on how they handle these situations to keep the game fair and fun.

The Dilemma: To Exploit or Not to Exploit?

As younger, more agile players, we often encounter a tricky situation when playing against those with limited mobility. Personally, I try to avoid taking advantage of their slower pace unless they start using similar tactics. But even then, I can’t help but notice the irritated glances, as if I’ve disrupted their game plan by playing fairly. It’s a bit ironic, considering these same opponents had no qualms about sending fastballs my way when I was a beginner struggling to keep up.

So, it raises a question: Is it fair to capitalize on an opponent’s limited mobility, or should we aim to keep the game balanced and enjoyable for everyone? It’s a tough call, but ultimately, the goal should be to have fun and ensure that everyone leaves the court feeling good about the game.

Balancing Skill and Mobility

Finding the right balance between skill and mobility in pickleball can be challenging, but it’s also where the game gets really interesting. One player shared their strategy: “I’d suggest using your advantage to extend the rally and keep the game competitive. Longer play means more fun and more experience for everyone.”

By placing your shots just out of reach—not too aggressively, but enough to keep the game competitive—you can practice your precision and shot placement without overwhelming your opponent. This approach makes the game enjoyable for everyone, as it keeps the match challenging yet fair, allowing both players to have a good time on the court.

Skill Level Matters

It’s crucial to consider the skill level of your opponent when playing. As one player noted, “If you’re much better than your opponent, repeatedly lobbing the ball to the 80-year-old with limited mobility is definitely bad sportsmanship.”

Instead, try to match your playing style to your opponent’s skill level. By focusing on placement and strategy rather than power, you can improve your game while ensuring your opponent also has a good time.

Playing Fair in Recreational Games

Playing with older or less mobile players can be incredibly rewarding. One player mentioned, “I often play with older players because I can balance out our mobility differences and keep the game enjoyable for everyone. After all, they were the ones who taught me the game.”

It’s a reminder that pickleball is not just about winning; it’s about enjoying the game and the people you play with. By adapting your play to ensure everyone has a good time, you honor the spirit of the sport and the contributions of those who helped you along the way.

Challenge Them When They Ask for It

Some players prefer to be challenged regardless of their mobility issues. One enthusiastic player shared, “I’m 65, a bit overweight, and have bad knees, but I want people to play their game. Don’t go easy on me for any reason.” They thrive on the challenge and see it as an opportunity to improve their skills and enjoy the game to the fullest.

Embracing the challenge means playing with intensity and treating every match as a chance to grow. For these players, the thrill of the game comes from pushing their limits and finding ways to adapt. So, when you encounter players who relish the challenge, don’t hold back—give them the game they crave.

Competitive Play vs. Recreational Play

When it comes to competitive play, all bets are off. In these settings, every player is out to win, and exploiting your opponent’s weaknesses is part of the strategy. As one player explained, “In high-level play, it’s crucial to leverage every advantage to win. Using your strengths and exploiting your opponents’ weaknesses is a fundamental part of the game.” This mindset is essential in tournaments and competitive leagues, where the stakes are higher, and the goal is to come out on top.

However, recreational play is a different story. Here, the focus is on fun, fitness, and friendly competition. It’s about striking a balance to ensure everyone enjoys the game. While it’s still important to play your best, being overly aggressive or exploiting a weaker opponent’s mobility can detract from the enjoyment. Instead, use recreational games as an opportunity to refine your skills, try out new strategies, and enjoy the social aspect of the sport.

Tips for Playing Against Lower Mobility Opponents

  • Communicate Clearly: Talk to your opponents before the game. Understand their comfort level and how competitive they want to play.
  • Adjust Your Play Style: Match your play style to your opponents’ abilities. Use less aggressive shots and focus on placement rather than power.
  • Keep It Fun: Remember that the goal of recreational play is to have fun. Winning isn’t everything.
  • Be Respectful: Avoid consistently targeting a player’s weakness. Mix up your shots to keep the game fair and enjoyable.

Ultimately, playing pickleball should be about having fun and enjoying the sport. While it’s okay to use your strengths, it’s also important to be considerate of your opponents’ limitations. By communicating openly and adjusting your play style, you can ensure that everyone has a great time on the court.


Q. Is it fair to exploit an opponent’s lack of mobility in pickleball?

Answer: It depends on the context. In competitive play, exploiting weaknesses is part of the strategy. However, in recreational play, it’s important to balance competitiveness with fairness to ensure everyone enjoys the game.

Q. How can I balance skill and mobility when playing against less mobile opponents?

Answer: Focus on extending rallies and using shot placement rather than power. This approach keeps the game competitive and enjoyable for both players.

Q. What should I do if my opponent prefers to be challenged despite their mobility issues?

Answer: Respect their preference and play your game. Some players thrive on the challenge and see it as an opportunity to improve their skills.

Q. How can I ensure that recreational pickleball games are fun for everyone?

Answer: Communicate with your opponents, adjust your play style to match their abilities, and focus on having fun rather than just winning.

Q. Is it bad sportsmanship to target a weaker opponent’s mobility?

Answer: In recreational play, consistently targeting a weaker opponent’s mobility can be seen as bad sportsmanship. It’s better to mix up your shots and play in a way that keeps the game fair and enjoyable for everyone.

What do you think?

Written by Billy Pickles

Level Up Your Drop & Dink Game: Learn This Technique and Watch Your Accuracy Soar

Why Defense Might Be Your Pickleball Downfall